Best Comforters on Amazon, Tested by Bedding Experts
Whether you sleep hot or prefer a down alternative, these comforters have thousands of positive reviews.
We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.
Our bedding experts in the Good Housekeeping Institute Textiles Lab tested over 100 comforters and duvet inserts in recent years, and some of the best bed comforters are available on Amazon. That means you can save a bit of money and you can get your new comforter ASAP, thanks to Amazon’s free two-day shipping if you’re a Prime member.
Our top picks:
- Best overall: Buffy Cloud Comforter
- Best value: Bedsure Comforter Duvet Insert
- Best for hot sleepers: REST Cooling Comforter
- Best down: Pacific Coast Goose Down Fiber Comforter
- Best lightweight: SlumberCloud UltraCool Comforter
To find the best comforters on Amazon, our experts evaluated the construction and materials of each comforter. We also send comforters to consumer testers to sleep with it at home and provide us with detailed survey responses describing their experience. That helps us choose comforters for hot sleepers that are great at keeping you cool while you sleep as well as duvet inserts that won’t shift around as you toss and turn. The Buffy Cloud Comforter is our best overall pick, not just on Amazon, but out of all the comforters we’ve ever tested.
Best Deal
Pros
- Temperature-regulating outer cover helps keep you cool
- Feels smooth and silky
- Fill stays fluffy
Cons
- Smooth outer material may make it shift around inside a duvet cover
WHO IT’S BEST FOR: Anyone looking for an overall amazing comforter that works with and without a duvet cover will like this smooth, cozy blanket.
WHY WE LOVE IT: We appreciate the Tencel lyocell outer cover that's designed to be lightweight, temperature-regulating, and quiet (i.e., it doesn't make a crinkly sound when you shift around).
IN OUR EVALUATIONS: We named Buffy's Cloud Comforter the best overall in our latest test of the best comforters due to its innovative construction. It has a Global Recycling Standard-certified down alternative fill made from plastic bottles that is composed of a web of individual fibers—this helps the comforter feel full and fluffy.
One consumer tester said that the duvet insert was so smooth that it “made [her] almost not want to use a duvet cover!” Another tester shared, “It’s perfect for summer nights or hot sleepers such as myself. When I got into bed, it almost felt cool, which I loved!” Although it has corner ties to help hold it in place, some of our testers said the material of the insert is just a little slippery and shifted around inside a duvet cover, so you may even prefer sleeping without one.
READ OUR FULL REVIEW: Buffy Comforter
| Fill material | Polyester |
| Outer cover | Tencel lyocell |
| Care | Machine wash cold; tumble dry low or air fluff |
Pros
- Budget-friendly price
- Light yet comfortable
- Does not cause overheating
Cons
- Not made with luxurious materials
WHO IT’S BEST FOR: Priced at under $35 (and even lower when there’s a sale), those on a budget will appreciate this well-made comforter.
WHY WE LOVE IT: While it’s not made with the most luxurious materials, the polyester cover feels smooth, and the polyester fill helps keep the price low. It’s available in 11 sizes and more than 17 colors, so you can match your room’s aesthetic without needing to buy a separate a duvet cover.
IN OUR EVALUATIONS: Our Textiles Lab pros ran this comforter through the washing machine and dryer multiple times, and the comforter held up well. Plus, our consumer testers said it stayed in good condition over multiple years of use.
Home & Apparel Reviews Analyst Amanda Constantine has bought four of these comforters for her home. She said she doesn’t wake up with night sweats with this thin comforter, and our consumer testers also said it was lightweight and didn’t feel too warm. One tester said, “It was light and comfortable and did not feel heavy," while another shared that the weight was still “very comforting.”
| Fill material | Polyester |
| Outer cover | Polyester |
| Care | Machine wash gentle; tumble dry on low |
Pros
- Keeps you cool
- Great for keeping you dry if you suffer from night sweats
- Soft, smooth material
Cons
- Cooling effects don't work as well if you use a duvet cover
WHO IT’S BEST FOR: Hot sleepers will like this lightweight comforter that feels cold to the touch.
WHY WE LOVE IT: REST relies on fabric structure and thermal conductivity rather than cooling additives to achieve a chilly feel. It’s thin, lightweight, but still feels comforting, so it’s a great pick for every season of the year.
IN OUR EVALUATIONS: The comforter aced moisture-wicking evaluations in the Textiles Lab, and we named it the best moisture-wicking comforter because multiple testers commented on how it helped with night sweats. The cooling properties of this comforter were not as effective with a duvet cover on it, so if you don’t love the appearance or the six color options, it may not be the best option for you.
One of our consumer testers said the comforter “feels soft and cool (almost icy even), providing much-needed relief in hot weather and wicking away any night sweats for a restful sleep.” Another consumer tester shared, “I was skeptical because this comforter is so thin, but I swear this comforter is magic! Since using the Rest comforter, I have been comfortable all night long!” Other testers found the material to be silky smooth and soft.
| Fill material | Down alternative (Sorona filling) |
| Outer cover | Nylon/spandex |
| Care | Machine wash cold; tumble dry low or drip dry |
Pros
- Evenly distributed fill so no cold spots
- Not too heavy but not too light
- Kept our testers at a comfortable body temperature all night
Cons
- Some of our testers found it to be a bit noisy
WHO IT’S BEST FOR: Someone wanting a down comforter at a budget-friendly price will like this pick on Amazon.
WHY WE LOVE IT: Down comforters are luxuriously soft and comfortable, but they can get pricey. This one is under $200, and its fill is a blend of goose down fiber (50%), goose feather fiber (40%), goose down (5%), and goose feathers (5%). That helps keep the price low, but still utilizes down materials. Constantine said, “This material is so luxurious because it is filled with lofty clusters of down that trap air, which provides outstanding insulation while remaining fluffy and lightweight.” We also like that the down fill is certified by the Responsible Down Standard (RDS), which verifies traceability in the supply chain.
IN OUR EVALUATIONS: Constantine says this comforter is “well constructed with a baffle-box design to evenly distribute the fill material,” which helps the comforter feel equally weighted across the bed, and the fill won’t roll over to one side. The corner loops worked well for tying it onto a duvet cover, too.
Our consumer testers found that this comforter was a bit noisy, but they loved that it kept them at a comfortable temperature throughout the night. One shared, “I liked that despite the thinness of the comforter at first glance, it kept me warm on some very cold nights.” Plus, it’s not too heavy but not too light, either. “It's a good weight—not so light that I can easily kick off in my sleep or so heavy that it feels uncomfortable,” says Grace Wu, a senior product analyst in our Textiles Lab.
RELATED: The Best Down Comforters
| Fill material | Goose down and feather blend |
| Outer cover | Cotton and polyester blend |
| Care | Machine wash in a large, non-agitator washer |
Pros
- Temperature-regulating materials to keep you cool
- Silky outer fabric
- Lightweight design
Cons
- Smooth outer cover can cause it to slip off bed
WHO IT’S BEST FOR: Those who run hot will appreciate this lightweight comforter with cooling technology.
WHY WE LOVE IT: Constructed with Outlast technology, the temperature-regulating fill of this comforter stores and releases body heat. That way, your body will maintain a comfortable body temperature all night long.
IN OUR EVALUATIONS: Our pros said the comforter’s cotton outer fabric felt luxe and silky, and our consumer testers loved sleeping with it. One tester reported that they didn’t overheat while using this comforter and said, “What ISN'T to like about this comforter? Holy moly, it is AMAZING.” This comforter was also easy to machine wash, but some testers found that the soft, silky outer cover made the comforter fall off their beds sometimes.
| Fill material | Polyester |
| Outer cover | Cotton |
| Care | Machine wash cold on gentle; tumble dry low |
Pros
- Heavy, snuggly feel
- Testers said it was warm without making them overheat
- Works well with a duvet cover
Cons
- Fill can become uneven at times
WHO IT’S BEST FOR: Those who like the feel of a heavyweight comforter while they sleep
WHY WE LOVE IT: This down-alternative comforter is available in three different weights, and we love that the “heavyweight” option provides a snuggly, comforting, heavy feel. We like that it’s made with a recycled polyester microgel fill to make the comforter fluffy. Brooklinen also offers a lengthy 365-day return policy for a $9.95 fee, so if you don’t like it even after a few months, you can still get your money back.
IN OUR EVALUATIONS: Our consumer testers found this comforter to be warm and cozy without causing them to overheat underneath. They liked that the comforter was quiet and soft. Plus, testers said it was easy to put inside a duvet cover and that it didn’t shift around. That way, you can get a cover that matches your room’s style. While this comforter has a baffle-box construction to keep the fill in place, some of our consumer testers said the fill sometimes became uneven.
| Fill material | Recycled polyester microgel fill |
| Outer cover | Cotton |
| Care | Machine wash cold; tumble dry low with dryer balls |
Pros
- Popular pick among Amazon customers
- Affordable
- Corner loops to keep it in place in a duvet cover
Cons
- Not the softest outer material
WHO IT’S BEST FOR: Anyone looking for an affordable comforter that’s a favorite among customers can check out this $30 pick.
WHY WE LOVE IT: This duvet insert is a popular pick online, thanks to its affordable price and wide range of sizes and colors. Its unique siliconized fiber filling is designed to create a comfortable feel, and it has four corner tabs (like almost all comforters) to help any duvet cover you put on it stay in place.
WHAT ONLINE CUSTOMERS SAID: This duvet insert has racked up over a hundred thousand reviews on Amazon, with the majority of those reviews being five-star. One satisfied customer writes, "Perfect weight, soft to the touch, not too hot, looks great on the bed. Arrived quickly and just as described.”
It’s made with a polyester outer shell and a down alternative fill material, yet it’s much less expensive than our other picks. It even has corner tabs to connect it to a duvet cover so that it stays in place, which you may need to buy since some online reviewers said it’s not the softest material. One wrote, “Not the biggest fan of the material. I thought it was a thicker outside material, but it is more like a scratchy material, kind of abrasive.” The good news is that since it’s only $30, it won’t be too much of a splurge to also purchase a duvet cover.
| Fill material | Siliconized polyester |
| Outer cover | Polyester |
| Care | Machine wash cold on gentle; tumble dry air fluff or line dry |
What to look for when shopping for a comforter on Amazon
Here are a few factors to keep in mind as you scroll through the many options online:
✔️ Construction: Comforters either have a baffle box construction, which means there are vertical lines in the fabric to help keep the fill in place, or a box stitch construction, which has square sections similar to a quilt. While the latter is less expensive and can be sufficient, box stitching doesn't keep fill in place as well as baffle box.
✔️ Outer fabric: Typically, the best comforters have a 100% cotton outer layer with a thread count of at least 300. You want a high enough count so the fabric is tightly woven to prevent the fill from poking through. If you are looking for more affordable options, a polyester or lyocell outer layer are good choices (and thread count only matters with cotton fabrics).
✔️ Fill material: Many comforters are made from down, a fluffy cluster from the undercoat of duck and geese. Down is best at providing even distribution but a down alternative fill like polyester is a great animal-free option. Plus, newer constructions mean polyester comforters are becoming more breathable with better temperature regulation. There are also comforters that have a fill made from recycled plastic if you want a more sustainable pick.
✔️ Price: Amazon's selection of comforters can range in value from around $30 to $80 on the less expensive end, to closer to $175 or more on the higher end. Consider your budget as well as what elements of a comforter's design matter most to you and your comfort.
How we test comforters
In the Good Housekeeping Institute Textiles Lab, our fiber scientists and product analysts evaluate comforters and duvet inserts each year. We inspect the comforters in the Textiles Lab and also send the comforters to consumer testers to report back on their experience sleeping with them at home. These are the key features we test for and evaluate for each comforter:
✔️ Construction: Our pros evaluate the comforters’ seams, stitching, and feel of the material. They take note of any corner loops or tabs, baffle-box or box-stitch design, and if there are any odors after opening the package.
✔️ Washability: In the Textiles Lab, our pros launder each comforter and assess the shrinkage, clumping, drying times, and note any changes in appearance.
✔️ Comfort: We consider feedback from consumer testers who share their thoughts on overall comfort, the feel of the outer fabric material, and the weight of the comforter.
✔️ Temperature: Our testers share whether the comforter made them overheat or kept them at a comfortable body temperature throughout the night. We also assess any cooling features in the Textiles Lab and verify any cooling technology claims from the brand.
✔️ Noise level: Some comforters and duvet inserts can have a crinkly noise, so we evaluate whether the comforter is noisy and ask our consumer testers to rate the noisiness on a scale of one to five.
✔️ Certifications: We also check and verify whether any claims made by the brand are validated by trusted third parties like the Global Recycling Standard, Global Organic Textiles Standard, and Organic Content Standard.
What is a good quality comforter made of?
A good quality comforter has a cotton outer fabric, down fill material, and baffle box construction. But that doesn't mean less expensive Amazon duvet inserts with a polyester or lyocell outer fabric, down alternative fill, or box stitch construction are bad quality—they just may not last as long. Ultimately, it comes down to your material preference and budget.
How should I wash my comforter?
While some comforters are dry clean only, all of the comforters featured in this article are machine washable. However, make sure there's enough room for the comforter to move freely in the washer and dryer. You might need to use a large-capacity or commercial-grade machine. For best results, add dryer balls and pause the drying cycle midway to manually fluff the comforter, which helps prevent clumping.
What's the difference between a duvet and a comforter?
Technically, comforters are meant to be used on their own, while duvet inserts go inside a duvet cover. Though the terms duvet and comforter are often used interchangeably, all the comforters we recommend on this list can be used either way. Stand-alone comforters skip the need for a duvet cover, while using one allows for easier cleaning and protects the comforter, extending its lifespan.
Why trust Good Housekeeping?
The Good Housekeeping Institute Textiles Lab consistently tests comforters. We also send comforters to consumer testers to sleep with them at home multiple nights and report back by filling out detailed surveys. We then use the Textiles Lab data and consumer tester feedback to select our top picks.
Isabella Cavallo is the editorial commerce editor at the GH Institute, and she is the author of this article. She reviews all sorts of products, including mattresses, home goods, bedding, and more.
To write this story, she consulted Home & Apparel Analyst Amanda Constantine. She has been testing bedding, including comforters, mattress toppers, and sheets, in the Textiles Lab since 2022. She regularly tests comforters for new articles and Good Housekeeping's Bedding Awards program.
