If you're a caregiver, you know how challenging finding the perfect gift for that special child in your life can be. Of course, you want it to be something they'll be excited to open and play with. But more than that, you want something that's safe, that’s not a pain to unbox, that's relatively easy to assemble (if necessary) and that's going to keep a child’s attention for more than a few minutes. And if it offers some kind of educational and developmental strengthening, even better.

It’s a tall order, but that's why the Good Housekeeping Institute team comes in. Our long-standing Toy Awards program — this is our fifteenth year! — was created to help ease this often overwhelming process. The Good Housekeeping Institute Parenting and Pets Lab combs the marketplace for the entire year, keeping track of new toy releases and staying on top of trends. The Lab then takes the top toys and calls them in for testing, where experts, parents and — most importantly — kids get to weigh in and choose the winners.

Meet the Judges

festive lifestyle shot of ribbons and string with headshots of toy awards judges

How We Tested

toy awards

Our team of experts at the Good Housekeeping Institute got hands-on with every product submission. And the evaluation started before the toys were even played with, by physically unboxing each entrant and seeing how easy or difficult it was. Then it was on to assembly, and notes were made on how simple or complex that task was too. After that, our experts checked for quality. How well constructed was each toy? Did they pass all the necessary safety checks? We verified compliance with ASTM testing standards, and also performed our own in Lab and at-home assessments.

After that came the true test: Kids played with the toys! We sent submissions to more than 450 kids of all ages, all across the country, to help us assess them and find the best of the best.

What this list delivers are toys that are safe, well-designed and well–constructed; that inspire a child’s imagination and creativity; that foster problem-solving skills; that encourage social play; that build skills (fine-motor, gross-motor, math, science, artistic and more); and that are just plain fun.

Even after this thorough evaluation, there are reasons a top-tested toy may not make it onto our list even if kids find it completely enjoyable. Sometimes, through assembly and use, we found out that toys (like science kits with certain dyes and craft sets that use colored dough) can stain the floor or kids’ clothing and skin. Sometimes we discovered that a toy isn’t very durable and may not hold up to repeated use. And sometimes we learned that a toy required intense supervision or that a parent had to expend a significant amount of time or effort to assemble it. All these factors and many more go into our decision process in finding the best toys.

The picks here are arranged in price ranges, in age order within each, to help you ID the perfect gift for every kid on your list.

Toy Awards by Price:
Under $30
| $30–$60 | $60 and Above

section header under 30 with festive holiday decor
Mike Garten

Toys Under $30
toy awards
Mike Garten

Toys $30 - $60
toys over $60

Toys $60 and Above