Every time news of a Jellycat release lands in my inbox, I swear I’m not going to buy more (as a toy editor, I have enough!)—but the new Halloween collection has me second-guessing myself. Known for creating the most unique collectible stuffed animals, Jellycat keeps finding new ways to steal our hearts (and money) season after season.

Shop Jellycat’s Halloween Collection

Of the spooky new collection, Growlston Gargoyle is my favorite because of its textured fur and tufted beard—but the Vampop drink is a clever way to nod to vampire lore (with a food twist that only Jellycat has truly mastered with its Amuseables line). While I tend to prefer the offbeat options, there’s traditional Halloween fare, too, including a pumpkin, mummy, ghost, and bat that are perfect for seasonal snuggling.

Remember: Jellycat cuties tend to sell out quickly or retire. In fact, some of my favorites from the Halloween collection have already sold out (like Skeleton Bob)—so if you’re obsessed, don’t wait too long...or you’ll see a frightful out-of-stock message.