It’s extremely easy to become a creature of habit while shopping—navigating directly towards certain sections we deem “high-priority” and automatically skipping over others.
But when it comes to thrifting, taking in everything the store has to offer is the key to finding those transformative pieces that can take your space to the next level.
"We always tell people to shop for character, not perfection. A little wear, an unusual shape, or a beautiful patina can be exactly what makes something special. The best homes feel collected over time, and thrift stores are one of the greatest places to find pieces that tell a story," says Barry and Jordan of The Brownstone Boys.
In order to find the most overlooked thrift store sections and finds, we turned to the pros. Here’s what to look out for next time you’re on the hunt for a hidden gem.
Charming Hardware
Designers recommend taking a second look at that thrift store bin filled with mismatched knobs, drawer pulls, hinges, and hooks.
“One of the first places we look is the hardware section,” says The Brownstone Boys. “People tend to overlook these pieces because they aren't always sold as complete sets, but that's part of their charm. A few vintage brass knobs can completely transform a basic dresser or cabinet. We always say that hardware is the jewelry of a home, and sometimes the smallest details make the biggest impact.”
Vintage Linens
Sure, there might be a few worn-out towels or cloths in the linen section. But there also might be cozy quilts, solid-colored shams, and patterned pieces, too.
“Thrift store linens are easy to breeze past, but it’s always worth taking a glance through the section,” says Diane Luna of Diane Luna Interior Design. “Currently, I’m on the hunt for vintage toile fabrics to use as the backdrop for my pattern-on-pattern fall tablescape. There’s something so special about vintage linens—they feel like home.”
Enamelware, Silverware & Glassware
Designers agree: If there’s one section not to skip, it’s kitchenware. Vintage enamelware, silverware, and glassware are worth hunting for—even if you don’t end up using them in the kitchen.
“I love looking for old enamelware. They are timeless, sculptural, colorful, and playful,” says Barrett Cooke of Arterberry Cooke. “If the enamel isn't in the best shape, the items can be used as vases, planters, or for non-food display.”
Kira Young of High Tide Design recommends double checking the silverware section, too: “They might look a bit crusty, but that’s the point. I love finding silver bowls that have a little bit of patina. They look really good against wood and work really well as a catchall at the entry console or your nightstand.”
And while you’re still perusing all-things-kitchen related, make sure to swing by the glassware aisle.
“One way to add interest to your dinner table is to use mix-and-match glasses. Most shoppers will skip the odd options, but you’ll become a place-setting superstar by purposely picking mismatched pieces. Place a different glass at each seat to bring an unexpected magic to your table,” says Luna.
Piles of Art
Sorting through piles of art at the thrift store is a time commitment, but that doesn’t mean it’s not worth every minute.
“The thrift store art pile is like a wide river just waiting to be gold-panned. So many nuggets! Most people avoid the haphazard piles of frames. But, friends, those stacks are worth sifting,” says Luna. “The key is to place your thrift store finds somewhere special in your home. In the right setting, a thrifted piece becomes a designer treasure.”
Old Frames
Ever heard of the phrase don’t judge a book by its cover? Designers recommend taking this wisdom with you into the thrift store.
“Never judge a frame by what's inside it,” says The Brownstone Boys. “We're constantly looking for beautiful old wood frames, ornate gilded details and interesting shapes. Often, the artwork itself isn't something we'd use, but the frame is the real treasure. We love mixing vintage frames with contemporary art, family photographs, or even small pieces of antique wallpaper. It's an affordable way to create a collected, layered look.”
Small Wooden Furniture
Bigger isn’t always better.
“Everyone gravitates toward the big statement pieces, but we're always drawn to the forgotten little wooden stools, side tables, and occasional chairs tucked into corners,” says The Brownstone Boys.
It’s all about thinking outside of the box and finding everyday use for those smaller antiques. They might not stand out as much while walking through the aisles of the store, but they sure will when they’re carefully placed throughout your home.
“A small antique stool can become a bedside table, a plant stand, or an unexpected accent in a bathroom. We especially love pieces that show their age rather than trying to make everything look brand-new.,” says The Brownstone Boys.
Laura Millar (she/her) is a freelance lifestyle journalist for Good Housekeeping. She holds a degree in Film, TV & Media from the University of Michigan, and was previously the assistant lifestyle editor for GH, where she covered home design. Her byline has appeared in NBC's TODAY.com, PEOPLE, Real Simple, and Business Insider.
